Breaking News
Latest News

Warren council to consider overturning voters’ decision on pay increases

By Ed Runyan 5 min read
Meeting

WARREN -- At Monday's regular Warren City Council meeting, council members will be asked to vote on two ordinances that would overturn the referendum Warren voters approved at the Nov. 3 general election that rejected the pay raises Warren City Council approved for itself and other top elected officials in 2023.

Both ordinances request that they be approved as emergency legislation, meaning that the requirement for three readings would be waived so that the legislation could take effect immediately "for the immediate preservation of public peace, health, welfare and safety."

The first ordinance on Monday's agenda states that the referendum language violated the Ohio Constitution and Ohio law by reducing the pay of elected officials "in-term," meaning during the term for which they were elected, and because the referendum was not permitted because Warren does not have a charter form of government.

The ordinance states that council "must clarify the compensation of city officials now" for the term of office that begins Jan. 1, 2028 to adhere to the law. The proposed legislation then goes on to state what the pay rate of the same nine top officials named in the referendum petition would be starting Jan. 1, 2028 in their new term of office -- the mayor ($55.98 per hour, $116,436 per year), service-safety director ($53.98 per hour, $112,278 per year), law director ($54.53 per hour, $113,422 per year), auditor ($54.53 per hour, $113,422 per hour), deputy auditor ($51.80 per hour, $107,744 per year), multiple deputy law directors ($51.80 per hour, $107,744 per hour), 11 council members ($16,500 per year) and treasurer ($881 every two weeks, $22,912 per year).

Under the referendum, the pay of the nine top officials was going to be frozen at the dollar amount that they made in 2026.

According to a document from the Warren Auditor's Office, the current pay of the same nine top officials is mayor, $107,464; service and safety director, $105,314; law director, $106,389; auditor ($106,389 per year), deputy auditor, $101,069 per year; multiple deputy law directors, $95,750 per year); and treasurer ($21,493 per year).

The $16,500 annual salary of council members called for in the ordinance on Monday's agenda is the same amount that was called for in the Nov. 3 referendum, not the amount City Council approved for itself in 2023 of $21,493 in 2026.

Warren City Council members also became eligible for city health care coverage as part of the 2023 legislation, but the cost of the health insurance is not part of the $21,493 that council members are earning in 2026. Under the legislation on Monday's agenda, council members would continue to get city health care.

The Nov. 3 referendum took away automatic pay raises for the nine top city officials. It required the pay to remain at a fixed amount until changed by a vote of the public.

The legislation on Monday's agenda states that language in the Nov. 3 referendum requiring the public to approve future pay increases for city council members and the nine top city officials conflicts with the Ohio Constitution and state law, so those provisions would be "rescinded immediately upon passage of this ordinance."

Warren City Council member Tina Milner said she will vote against the legislation, saying it displays "arrogance and entitlement that just blows me away." She said the legislation on the agenda Monday "totally usurps the the will of the voters" at the Nov. 3 election.

Milner said she believes that Law Director Enzo Cantalamessa met with most or all of the other City Council members except her to discuss this legislation. Milner said she was not on council when it approved the pay raises in 2023, but she did circulate a petition to get the referendum on the ballot and speak publicly in favor of the the referendum prior to the Nov. 3 vote.

She said she does not believe the argument the city law department is making in the resolutions that the referendum contained language that is contrary to state law. She said the Ohio Secretary of State's Office would not have approved putting the referendum on the ballot if it would have been contrary to state law.

When the sponsor of the legislation, Councilman Greg Greathouse, was asked if he asked the Warren Law Department to draft the legislation, he referred the question to the Warren Law Department.

James E. Walker, brother of Tina Milner and an activist who has been live-streaming Warren City Council meetings for about 10 years, issued a press release Saturday on the proposed legislation.

He stated that after 72% of Warren voters “said no” Nov. 3 to the raises council approved in 2023, “City Hall has drafted an ordinance that says their vote doesn’t count and labeled it as an emergency.” He said, “There is no emergency. Terms that start in 2028 do not need to be decided by Thanksgiving.”

According to the Ohio Questions and Issues Handbook by Ohio Secretary of State Frank LaRose, “Not all actions of a municipal legislative authority are subject to initiative or referendum proceedings. Some legislative enactments are expressly exempt from the referendum power; examples include ordinances and resolutions adopted as emergencies.”

The two pay ordinances are expected to be discussed at the caucus session that starts at 4:15 p.m. Monday in the caucus room adjacent to the City Council Chambers at 141 South Street SE and at the 5 p.m. regular council meeting. Council meetings typically occur on Wednesdays, but this one was moved to Monday because of the Thanksgiving holiday.

Starting at /week.