Trending
WARREN -- No hearings are scheduled yet in a civil suit former Warren Police Chief Eric Merkel filed Nov. 5 in Trumbull County Common Pleas Court asking Judge Cynthia Wescott or her successor to restore Merkel to the chief's job.
Assistant Trumbull County Prosecutor Chris Becker was elected in the Nov. 2 general election to replace Wescott as Trumbull County Common Pleas Court judge Jan. 1, after Wescott's current term of office ends. She did not run for reelection.
Many of the reasons Merkel cited in his 19-page lawsuit are similar to arguments Merkel made when asking the Warren Civil Service Commission to reinstate him to the position. That effort ended Oct. 5 when attorney Dan Letson and the two other members of the commission formally rejected Merkel's written and oral arguments and turned Merkel down by a 3-0 vote.
The civil suit, filed by two attorneys with the Cleveland-area Employment Law Partners firm, names as defendants Warren Service and Safety Director Eddie Colbert, Mayor Doug Franklin and the City of Warren.
Merkel, of Howland, argues that city officials failed to carry out a meaningful investigation of a complaint made against Merkel when it brought the complaint to Merkel and demanded that he resign or be fired.
It argues that the city also failed to provide Merkel with the "civil-service process to which he would be entitled" in a circumstance in which his employer was attempting to remove him from his job.
It cites Ohio law requiring officials to furnish Merkel with "a copy of the order of suspension, fine, demotion or removal" giving the reasons such action was being sought
It argues that the reasons for the termination had to be filed with the city's civil service commission, and Merkel was entitled to have the opportunity to file an appeal.
Merkel restates the series of events that led up to Merkel resigning as chief July 9 after being called into the mayor's office July 8 and informed of a complaint July 7 by an officer under Merkel's command, Frank Tempesta, who alleged that Merkel had been paid for time not worked and that Merkel had texted Tempesta a racially insensitive image.
"Contending they were disturbed by the allegations and ostensibly motivated by political concerns, Mayor Franklin and Director Colbert presented Chief Merkel with an ultimatum: resign or be terminated," the suit states.
"However, the allegations shared by (Colbert and Franklin) were unfounded and/or legally insufficient to justify the termination of a police chief who is a classified civil servant."
The suit seeks a ruling by a judge that when Merkel tried to rescind his resignation Aug. 23 , city officials acted contrary to case law in refusing to allow Merkel to rescind his resignation. The suit asks that he be reinstated as chief because he had a right to rescind the resignation.
It notes that the steps the Warren Civil Service Commission have taken to give a test to select Merkel's replacement as chief, such as giving a promotional exam Dec. 16 with a deadline to apply of Dec. 7, "threatens to place another another person in the office of chief of police" before Merkel can litigate whether his termination was fair.
The suit argues that Merkel's "purported resignation was was involuntary" and that he was removed from the position in violation of state law. It argues that the removal was done because the "asserted bases for termination were false, unfounded, pretetual and/or legally insufficient to support removal" under Ohio law.
It asks the court to restore Merkel to the police chief's position and seniority, back pay, lost benefits and pension and other compensation, including economic, non-economic and punitive damages against Colbert and Franklin "based on their malicious, willful and/or conscious disregard for Chief Merkel's rights.
Last week, Franklin and Colbert, as the two members of the Warren Board of Control, authorized payment of $60,000 to the Baker, Dbublikar law firm of North Canton for services associated with the "resignation of Chief of Police."
Warren officials have not yet filed a response to the lawsuit.