Breaking News
Editorials

Vote yes: End the council hikes that never stop

By James E. Walker 8 min read

Most Warren families get a raise when they earn one, if they get one at all. The politicians at City Hall wrote themselves a better deal: a raise that arrives on its own, every January and every July, forever.

No vote. No hearing. No headline. Just a bigger paycheck, year after year, for as long as there is a city of Warren.

This November, voters finally get to stop it. The ballot asks: "Shall the Ordinance to immediately rescind and replace the pay raises for City Council in Warren, Ohio, and eliminate all future automatic increases for elected officials, be passed?" Vote YES.

Here is what council did. On Nov. 8, 2023, it voted 8-2 to set the mayor's pay at 1% above the city's highest-paid employee and to peg every other elected official to the mayor. Council's own pay jumped 89%, from $11,109 to $20,974. Council also voted itself city health and life insurance. The mayor went from $87,796 to $104,873 by 2025. The first year alone cost taxpayers $260,145.

Then comes the part that never ends. Every time the city's highest-paid employee gets a union raise, the mayor gets one, and so does everyone tied to the mayor. The city's own pay chart shows 2% raises in January and July, year after year. Council never has to vote on its own pay again. It just collects.

A YES vote sets council pay at $16,500 and freezes elected officials' pay until voters approve a change. It does not touch police, firefighters or any union worker. As former Councilman Ken MacPherson put it, "It has nothing to do with employees who are not elected, only elected officials."

John Brown can't have it both ways

In November 2023, Council President John Brown wanted Warren to know where he stood. Brown votes only to break a tie, so he never had to cast a vote on the raises. But he told the Tribune Chronicle he "did not support the legislation." In his words: "I do not concur with the members of council who sponsored this legislation."

Nearly three years later, with voters about to decide, Brown sang a different tune. He told WKBN he understands the issue is up to residents, but he believes he has earned his paycheck.

Which John Brown should voters believe? The one who opposed the raise when it cost him nothing to say so? Or the one defending the bigger paycheck now that it is his?

A council president who truly opposed an 89% raise and an automatic escalator would welcome this vote. He would be out front asking for it. Instead, he is defending the money. Mr. Brown can clear this up with four words: "I'm voting yes, too." Until he says them, voters should judge him by what he says now, not what he said then.

The clerks got 7%. Council got 89%.

Five weeks after voting itself an 89% raise, council took up pay for the two women who run its office. Clerk Brenda Smith and Deputy Clerk Mellisa Hughes got 2% in January 2024, 2% in July 2024 and 3% in January 2025. That is about 7% in all. Smith's salary topped out at $56,269.

And then it stopped. Finance Chairman Greg Greathouse explained why the clerks' vote was urgent: "The last raise they had goes away at the end of this year and there's no mechanism for a salary adjustment."

Read that again. For the clerks, council wrote raises that run out, so the clerks must come back and ask again. For themselves, council built a raise that never runs out and never has to be asked for.

Greathouse said council tries to keep the clerks "in lockstep with the union." Council did not start itself in lockstep. It jumped 89% first, grabbed health insurance, and only then got in line for the union's raises. Forever.

Councilman Ron White called the clerks' raise "too light." "There's only two of them in the office but we have 10 people on council," he said. Then he voted for it anyway. White had voted for council's 89%.

The two people who answer the phones and keep the records got 7% and an expiration date. The 10 people they serve got 89%, health coverage and a raise machine. That tells you whose interests this council puts first.

What "forever" costs

The raises depend on future union contracts, so no one can know the exact numbers. But we can do the math at three speeds. The city's pay chart shows two 2% raises a year, which compounds to about 4% a year. If contracts slow down, it could be 3% or even 2%. Starting from the 2025 salaries in the city auditor's own chart, here is where the pay goes if voters do nothing.

Position

2025 pay

In 10 years

In 20 years

In 30 years

Mayor

$104,873

$127,800 - $155,800

$155,800 - $231,600

$190,000 - $344,100

Law director

$103,812

$126,500 - $154,300

$154,300 - $229,200

$188,000 - $340,600

Auditor

$103,812

$126,500 - $154,300

$154,300 - $229,200

$188,000 - $340,600

Safety-service director

$102,772

$125,300 - $152,700

$152,700 - $226,900

$186,200 - $337,200

Council member (each)

$20,974

$25,600 - $31,200

$31,200 - $46,300

$38,000 - $68,800

Low figure: 2% a year. High figure: two 2% raises a year, the pace in the city's 2024-2025 pay chart. Rounded to the nearest $100.

A part-time council seat that paid $11,109 in 2023 could pay nearly $69,000 in 30 years. That is more than twice what the typical Warren household earns today.

Add it up. The mayor, law director, auditor, safety-service director and 11 council seats cost about $646,000 a year in 2025. Over the next 30 years, the automatic raises alone would add about $7.4 million at 2% a year, $12.3 million at 3%, and $18.6 million at today's pace. That is before health insurance, pensions, and the deputies whose pay is pegged to their bosses'.

There is a conflict built into this, too. Every union contract council approves now raises council's own pay. The Tribune Chronicle warned in 2023 that this gives council "an unethical private interest in a public vote." It was right.

Warren measures its police against Mansfield. Why not its politicians?

When Warren sits down to bargain with its police officers, the city looks at what Mansfield pays its officers. Mansfield is a fair yardstick: a similar Ohio industrial city, and a bigger one, with about 47,500 residents to Warren's 38,200.

City leaders are happy to use that yardstick on the officers who patrol our streets. They never used it on themselves. So we did.

Position

Warren

Mansfield

Mayor

$104,873 (2025)

$100,285 (2026)

Law director

$103,812 (2025)

$93,594 (2026)

Auditor (Mansfield: finance director)

$103,812 (2025)

$93,594 (2026)

Safety-service director

$102,772 (2025), fixed at 98% of the mayor

Appointed; pay range $70,000 - $105,000 set by council

Treasurer

20% of the mayor's pay from 2026, rising automatically

No elected treasurer

Council member

$20,974

$9,263 (2026)

Police chief

About $103,800 (July 2025 rate)

Not published

Patrol officer

About $60,000 - $87,000 (2026 posting)

$60,843 - $83,446 (2026)

Warren figures are 2025 rates; Warren's 2026 pay is higher still. Mansfield figures are 2026 rates.

Look at the bottom row first. Warren and Mansfield patrol officers are paid about the same. That is what comparing to Mansfield is supposed to do.

Now look at the top. Even comparing Warren's 2025 pay to Mansfield's 2026 pay, Warren's mayor earns more than the mayor of a bigger city. Warren's law director and auditor each make about $10,000 more than their Mansfield counterparts. And a Warren council member earns more than twice what a Mansfield council member earns.

Mansfield's raises are also written down in plain dollars, and they end in 2027. To go higher, Mansfield's council must vote again, in public, with its name on the roll call. Warren's politicians gave themselves a formula so they never have to face that vote again.

If Mansfield is good enough to hold down the pay of the officers who risk their lives for this city, it is good enough for the politicians who sit behind the dais.

Forever ends only if you vote YES

Supporters will say council went 15 years without a raise. Fine. Then they should have asked voters for a fair, fixed raise with an end date, the way Mansfield did and the way they treated their own clerks. Instead they took 89%, added health insurance, and wired their pay to every union contract for the rest of time.

In a city where the median household earns about $30,000 and roughly one in three residents lives below the poverty line, that is not a pay adjustment. It is an entitlement.

Remember what "automatic" means. Every January and every July, about 2% more, compounded, with no vote and no end. In 10 years, the mayor's job could pay $155,800. In 20, $231,600. In 30, more than $344,000. A part-time council seat could approach $69,000. And you will never again get a chance to say no.

Except this once.

A YES vote does not punish anyone. Council would still earn $16,500, nearly 50% more than it did before 2024. The mayor and the other officials keep their pay, frozen where it stands. The only thing that changes is who decides future raises. Today, the politicians decide. After a YES vote, you do.

These raises are forever unless voters stop them. On Nov. 3, stop them. Vote YES.

JAMES E. WALKER

James E. Walker is a Warren resident.

Sources

WKBN, "Warren voters to decide whether to repeal council pay raises," Sept. 25, 2026

Tribune Chronicle, "Warren council approves pay raises," Nov. 9, 2023

Tribune Chronicle, "City OKs raises for clerk and deputy clerk," Dec. 14, 2023

Tribune Chronicle, "Top 10: Warren pay raises draw protest, petitions," Dec. 2023

Tribune Chronicle editorial, "Warren council must reject plan for pay raises," Oct. 26, 2023

Tribune Chronicle, "Warren council seeks 1st pay hike for elected officials in 15 years," Sept. 2023

WKBN, "City council candidate will petition to repeal raises for elected officials," Apr. 29, 2025

City of Warren pay chart, 2023-2025 (hourly rates; annual = rate × 2,080 hours)

Warren police recruiting posting, National Testing Network, 2026

Mansfield News Journal via Yahoo, "Mansfield City Council honors departing office holders," Dec. 2023 (Mansfield mayor, law and finance director salaries 2024-2027; safety-service director range)

Richland Source, "Robertson, Scott seek Mansfield City Council At-large seat," Oct. 30, 2025 (council pay $9,263 in 2026)

Mansfield Police Department careers page (2026 officer pay)

Mansfield Division of Police, Wikipedia (population 47,534)

Starting at /week.