Trending
Warren City Council today is expected to vote on legislation granting huge increases for elected city officials.
When we say huge, we mean exorbitant.
According to the proposed legislation, the mayor's salary must remain 1% higher than the base salary of the highest paid city employee.
Many other elected and appointed city officials also would see increases, all inextricably tied together as a%age of the mayor's salary.
If passed (and, despite our objections, we fully expect that it will) it will boost officials' salaries anywhere from about 19% to -- brace yourself -- 89%. In all, the raises will cost Warren taxpayers more than $260,145 in 2024 alone. And each time the highest paid city worker gets a raise, so will all our elected officials.
Here's how it would work. City police Chief Eric Merkel and fire Chief Ken Nussle are the highest paid city employees, each earning $95,929 per year, according to Warren Councilman Greg Greathouse, who proposed the legislation. Mayor Doug Franklin currently earns $87,796 per year. Increasing the mayor's salary to 1% more than the chiefs' would boost Franklin to $98,820 in 2024 and $104,873 by 2025, according to Warren Auditor Vince Flask.
That's more than a 19% increase in two years. It's unclear how these second-year raises will be given since Ohio law bans mid-term raises for elected officeholders. Our law director offered case law he says would permit it, but we expect that could be challenged in court.
Also proposed would be a raise for the city safety service director, currently Eddie Colbert, to make that position's salary 98% of the mayor's salary. Colbert earns $84,489. If the proposal passes, his salary would increase 22% within two years to $102,775.
The city's auditor would earn 99% of the mayor's salary, and the deputy auditor director would earn 95% of the auditor's salary. Flask currently earns $86,652 per year. Further, if passed, the city law director would earn 99% of the mayor's salary, the deputy law directors will earn 95% of the law director and assistant law directors will earn 90% of the law director.
Law Director Enzo Cantalamessa currently earns $80,724. The law director's salary would increase to $103,824.27 by 2025, or about a 29% increase.
Council members and the council president, meanwhile, would earn no less than 20% of the mayor's salary, or $20,974 each. That's $9,865 more than each currently earns -- $11,109.93 per year. The increase would mean 89% increases in pay for each part-time council member.
While we understand there comes a time when city leaders deserve a raise, we doubt any public servant ever would deserve an increase of this volume, especially in a city where the constituents footing the bill are earning a median income per household of $30,377. More than 30% of Warren residents live below poverty level.
We met recently with Greathouse at his request. Let us be clear. We respect Greathouse for requesting the meeting with our editorial board in an attempt to present his argument.
Greathouse told us the discussion began when elected officials said they struggle to retain good employees who could not receive raises because they were tied to their elected bosses' salaries.
Greathouse also stressed that it has been 15 years since any elected official in Warren received a pay increase, and he was hopeful these increases could help make up that lost income. He believes higher pay will help attract better candidates and also help retain employees who answer to these elected officials who also could see increases.
We empathize with struggles to keep valued employees. But giving some raises to deserving city workers -- even to deserving elected officials -- does not have to mean an attempt to make up 15 years of lost wages, nor does it mean it should forever be tied to raises given to other city employees.
We disagree strenuously with any attempt to raise a public servant's salary by 89%, which is what part-time city council members will see if this issue passes tonight. And council's raises will come with the new offer of health benefits -- even though council seat are considered part-time.
For comparison, the city employs only two part-time workers. Neither is offered health insurance.
Heck, even Greathouse acknowledged the first wave of these raises probably will be viewed as a "tsunami." Future raises, tied to the base salary of the highest paid city employee would be more of a "trickle," he said.
We would not object as strenuously if the raises were a "trickle." They are not.
Council must rethink the structure of these pay adjustments and just say no to the enormity of them.