Breaking News
Editorials

Ohio should do away with double dipping

4 min read

In agreeing to the retire-rehire plan for two high-paid Howland managers and two other public works employees, township officials were quick to point out the township cannot pick and choose which employees may take advantage of the system that's available to any Howland employee who is eligible to retire.

But what officials failed to point out to taxpayers who are footing the bill for both their continuing salaries, as well as the public pension they receive, is they did have the ability to rehire these employees at a lower rate.

But Howland didn't do that.

Instead, trustees voted in recent months to grant the retirements requested by Administrator Darlene St. George, Assistant police Chief Jeffrey Urso, and public works employees Kris Dillon and John Perfette one day, and then rehire them all back the very next day at the exact same rates of pay.

St. George's $96,276 annual salary did not change when she was rehired. Nor did Urso's $75,507 salary. Dillon earns $66,218, and Perfette $52,333.

Also, all four rehired employees will not lose their seniority and will keep all accrued personal, sick and vacation time.

In explaining the plan to our reporter, township officials noted what they somehow seem to view as savings since they allowed these employees to keep their unused personal time rather than cashing it out. But let's face it, in reality, there was no real savings because allowing them to maintain this time simply means they'll cash it out later. And if they get pay raises between now and then, it's likely they'll cash it out at an even higher rate of pay.

So, really, who wins?

We have consistently opposed retire-rehire plans because we believe these programs are just another example of the ability for government employees to fleece taxpayers who don't enjoy similar options in the private sector, yet pay the bill for those in the public sector who do.

Thousands of public employees in Ohio reap rewards of a generous salary, all while collecting a pension at taxpayers' expense.

Given that state law permits relatively young retirees to double-dip, who can blame these and all eligible public workers for taking advantage? We see the true culprit in this longstanding misguided policy as the state law and pension fund rules that permit the questionable practice.

Contrast these public sector perks with those of the average private sector retiree. First, the company worker must wait generally until age 65 or older to qualify for full Social Security retirement benefits or, if he or she is lucky, for a private pension to kick in. The thought of collecting a paycheck and pension payments simultaneously is nothing more than a pipe dream to many in the private sector.

And if a private sector employee begins collecting Social Security benefits before reaching full retirement age, he or she is limited to earning $21,240 this year or face harsh penalties in the Social Security check.

If a worker earns more than $21,240 while collecting Social Security at less than full retirement age, the Social Security Administration will deduct $1 from benefit payments for every $2 a worker earns above the annual limit.

Still, government workers often are quick to defend the practice. In some cases, the salaries of double dippers are reduced -- usually ever so slightly -- once the pension perks roll in, creating the appearance that taxpayers are saving money. They also will argue that retaining the experience and expertise of seasoned public employees is priceless. But as more and more of Ohio's 400,000 public employees opt for retire-rehire, more and more young and well-trained individuals will be blocked from deserved promotions and even from the entrance door to satisfying employment.

It is long past time for Ohio pension systems and state statutes governing them to rein in such extravagance. They could start by raising retirement ages to those at least within the ballpark of the private sector.

They also could lay down more stringent requirements and less attractive benefits, including no additional earned pension benefits while working after retirement.

As state legislators are public workers themselves, it's not hard to see why action on leveling the playing field between private and public sector employees and retirees has not been a hot-button priority. In the narrow interest of pension-fund stability and in the wide interest of fairness to Ohio's working men and women in all sectors, state law governing retire-rehire needs to be scaled back drastically by our state legislators.

Starting at /week.