Breaking News
David Skolnick

Flask, Fortune remembered

By DAVID SKOLNICK 6 min read

While the election and then analysis of the results has been nearly all consuming, I feel the need to write about two people who recently died as they played huge roles in my start as a reporter in the area.

I'm referring to Edward Flask, a former attorney who was on the Mahoning Valley Sanitary District amid scandal, and James E. Fortune Sr., who spent 22 years on Youngstown City Council.

With their passings, the Mahoning Valley lost two of the most colorful characters I've ever known.

I came to this area in 1995, after seven years at smaller newspapers in New York state, and my first beat included covering Niles, Lordstown and the MVSD.

At the time, the MVSD was undergoing a $50 million capital improvement program and there was definitely numerous shady things going on.

I developed sources at the MVSD who would provide me with information. I followed up on that information and wrote a number of articles. Those articles led to the state auditor doing a special report in 1997 on the district and coming up with even more issues and concerns.

The local media would go to every MVSD meeting, which often went on for hours.

For some reason, Flask took a liking to me. Flask would refuse to talk to any other reporter, but he would wave me to sit with him inside his large automobile to tell me his side of what was occurring.

We would call each other regularly with Flask insisting he did nothing improper or illegal.

Despite my probing questions, Flask always talked to me.

He often shared stories about his law practice with Carmen Policy, his time serving as attorney to boxing legend Ray "Boom Boom" Mancini and his father's term as Youngstown mayor.

That 1997 state audit didn't paint Flask in a positive light and reporter Mark Niquette and I drove to Columbus early one morning to review thousands of pages of documents related to the report. In the documentation, we found that Flask was paid a considerable amount of money to serve as a consultant to several major companies. Niquette and I called all of the companies and learned that none of them knew anything about Flask. The article compared Flask to the Invisible Man.

Flask was removed from the MVSD board and a grand jury indicted him in 2000 on 16 criminal counts. It was a secret indictment, but a source gave me a copy of it about two or three days before it was unsealed.

We published the article about his secret indictment before it was made public.

Flask pleaded guilty to two felony counts of having an unlawful interest in a public contract and seven misdemeanors.

The felonies were for Flask taking nearly $2 million in total as a consultant from Blue Cross/Blue Shield of Ohio and Ohio Edison in exchange for authorizing a series of purchases at the MVSD.

The misdemeanors were for taking much smaller amounts from other companies doing work on the MVSD capital improvements.

Flask got 90 days in the Trumbull County jail.

It certainly wasn't hard time as Flask received many visitors and didn't spend much time in a cell.

As part of his conviction, Flask was ordered to repay the Ohio Ethics Commission for the $78,562 cost of his investigation.

Flask filed for bankruptcy after the state named him in a $2.4 million civil lawsuit, saying he couldn't pay that or the ethics fee. Flask withdrew the bankruptcy filing and the case never went anywhere with him paying a portion of the costs to the ethics commission.

Again, during all of this, Flask and I were in regular communication as he wanted to get his side of the story out.

It had been more than 20 years since I last saw or spoke to Flask. But his passing last month brought back a flood of memories of a different time in the Valley when politics was far more interesting and sketchy than now.

About a year or so after I moved here, I met Fortune - and for the same reason as Flask.

The MVSD was an incredibly hot topic and Youngstown City Council came to Niles council chambers to discuss the district, which the two cities jointly created.

Fortune, who was council's finance committee chairman at the time, was engaging and loved to talk.

I sat and listened.

Fortune represented Youngstown's 6th Ward before I ever got here. He first won the seat in 1981 and was reelected to what was then two-year terms until losing in a close 1991 Democratic primary. Fortune came back and won the 1993 election and served until he was elected council president in 2003 to fill the remaining two years on an unexpired term.

That 2003 election is unforgettable.

The Mahoning County Board of Elections provided results for the race showing John R. Swierz had won the Democratic primary by a small margin. Back then, my deadline to submit articles was around midnight so when the other reporters ran to get comments from Swierz, I hung back at the elections board.

It turned out that the board found uncounted votes from a precinct or two. After those votes were included, Fortune won by 25 votes.

I spoke to Fortune, who was very surprised by the outcome as he was essentially declared the loser. After other reporters spoke to Swierz about his "victory," I broke the news to him that he had actually lost.

Fortune served two years as council president while I covered Youngstown City Council.

Rather than run for reelection, Fortune sought to seek the mayoral position and lost in the 2005 Democratic primary.

When Fortune left Youngstown council, his 22 years of elected experience was only eight years less than the combined elected experience of the city's then seven ward council members. That's because term limits were put in place for council members. Since then, term limits were removed and later restored.

Along with Charles Sammarone, Fortune was the last of the longtime, old-school politicians to serve on Youngstown council.

NOTE: There will be no column next week.

David Skolnick covers politics for the Tribune Chronicle and The Vindicator.

Starting at /week.