Breaking News
Local News

Watkins opposes parole for man he prosecuted 51 years ago

By ED RUNYAN 3 min read
James Teague

WARREN -- Trumbull County Prosecutor Dennis Watkins prosecuted James Teague in May of 1975, obtaining convictions on aggravated murder and aggravated robbery in the June 8, 1974, shooting death of Masury pharmacy operator Charles Earnhart, a World War II pilot.

It was one of Watkins' first jury cases after graduating from law school and joining the Trumbull County Prosecutor's office. It has been more than 51 years since Teague was convicted and sentenced to life in prison for the murder and an additional sentence for the aggravated robbery.

But Watkins believes Teague, now 76, should be denied parole again -- not only because of the "crime wave" Teague carried out between 1970 and 1974, but because of his "volcano-like personality eruptions, which have resulted in victimization or devastation to many citizens and families through the years."

Watkins has written to the Ohio Parole Board opposing parole for Teague again, as he has in the past. Teague comes up for parole this time later this month. According to prison records, Teague is serving 15 years to life for killing Earnhart.

He also has another conviction out of Pennsylvania that carries a sentence of five to 25 years in prison for aggravated robbery that must be served after his Ohio sentences are complete. Teague has spent 50 1/2 years behind bars.

In Watkins' most recent letter to the parole board, he notes that he has asked the parole board on many previous occasions to keep Teague in prison.

He stated that Earnhart was 54 years old when Teague shot him five times, killing Earnhart as he ate a sandwich in his home. Watkins called Teague a "habitual offender with a history of violence."

Watkins said, "We continue to believe Teague deserves, because of his history, actions and gratuitous violence, to serve his full sentence and die in prison."

He said Teague's antisocial personality traits even though he is over 70 years of age, demonstrate that with freedom of movement in society, there will be a clear and present danger for others. Please do not take that step and thereby ensure public safety."

Watkins cited a 2017 letter Watkins wrote to the parole board that said Teague was first convicted of forgery and larceny in 1968 in Massachusetts at age 17.

Watkins' current letter updates Teague's prison disciplinary records with Teague's behavior improving over the past 10 years. Watkins stated that might have been because Watkins discussed it in 2017 as a reason to keep Teague locked up at that time.

"Thus he likely has played the game (of learned remorse syndrome) to argue that he should now be released," Watkins said, adding, "This guy has been for nearly five decades committing crime (or behavioral infractions) inside and outside of prison, including the 1960s, 1970s, 1980s, 1990s and 2000s."

Starting at /week.