Breaking News
Local News

Clearing the air about smoking ban

Smoking ban adversaries recall fight over public cigarettes

By Burton Cole 8 min read
Tribune Chronicle / Burton Cole One-time adversaries over proposed smoking bans — Robyn Hineman, left, of Cortland, and retired restaurant owner Bob Abruzzi of Warren — still bicker over their opinions on a smoking ban, but they also share laughs.

WARREN -- The one-time opponents sat together at a table in what used to be the nonsmoking section of the Mocha House and sorted through newspaper clippings documenting the battle.

Ohio's voter-enacted public places smoking ban went into effect 10 years ago in December. But it was 30 years ago this year that cities, schools, restaurants and hospitals in Trumbull County wrestled with smoking bans.

At the time, Robyn Hineman, a 20-something mother from Cortland, and Bob Abruzzi, then in his late 40s and the owner of Cafe 422 in Warren and a leader of the local restaurant association, were on the front lines. On this day, they reminisce about the debate from three decades ago.

Hineman slid a July 26, 1987, news clipping from her scrapbooks. The story proclaimed that Sparkle Market in Cortland had just gone smoke-free, largely at Hineman's pestering.

"People don't remember that we used to be able to smoke in restaurants and grocery stores," Hineman said. "That's why we started growing our garden. I would go to Sparkle Market in Cortland and see people with cigarettes leaning over the produce, their ashes falling on the produce.

"I remember going to a restaurant in Howland and they're smoking while they're preparing our food and the ashes are falling on the food. I'm thinking, 'Are you flipping kidding me?'"

Abruzzi shook his head. "But Robyn, my lovely friend, aren't you more sensitive to smoke than the average person? You must be."

Hineman's husband, Jack, answered. "I use this analogy: At Packard, I wore hearing protection. They (co-workers) said, 'Don't worry about it, you'll get used to it.' No, you'll lose your hearing. She never lost her sense of smell."

"The catalyst," Robyn said, "was when I was pregnant and I'm breathing for a baby. Everywhere I had to stand in line, the bank, the grocery story, etc., I was forced to stand there as people smoked. That was the line in the sand."

Her son was born in 1985. That was the year she began her fight for the freedom to breathe.

Abruzzi, a nonsmoker himself, said for him, the issues also centered on freedom.

"I wanted business to have a choice whether to go nonsmoking or not, and if they did, a choice in how they handled it," Abruzzi said.

Besides that, the restaurant association harbored a practical business fear over proposed smoking bans: "Losing our smoking customers, and quite frankly, they were big spenders. They had all the vices."

Hot-Button Issue

Smoking debates in Trumbull County were growing. Headlines from Tribune Chronicle archives from 30 years ago highlight some of the issues:

∫ Aug. 5, 1987: Hineman, owner of The Body Shop, secures commitments from 48 businesses to hang "no smoking signs" in their establishments and to support a proposal for the city to enforce a smoking ban.

∫ Aug. 19, 1987: The Warren Board of Education votes unanimously to ban students from smoking or chewing tobacco on school property. The district's high schools previously had designated smoking areas for students. Teachers and staff will continue to have designated smoking areas.

∫ Sept. 22, 1987: Warren's three hospitals -- Trumbull Memorial, St. Joseph Riverside and Warren General -- agree to ban smoking by Sept. 1, 1988. The three hospitals worked together on a plan they say will create a smoke-free environment for patients, staff and visitors.

∫ Sept. 15, 1987: An arbitrator will decide if teachers in Newton Falls have the right to smoke in school. Newton Falls is the only school district in Trumbull County that has approved a policy that prohibits teachers and all adults from smoking in school buildings, including in the gymnasium during sporting events, plays and band concerts. Teachers filed an unfair labor practices grievance in June over the policy established in May.

∫ Nov. 18, 1987: The Newton Falls Board of Education decides to fight an arbitrator's ruling that sides with teachers who want the district to retain designated smoking areas for staff.

∫ Dec. 6, 1988: Cortland City Council refuses to ban smoking but will consider an indoor clean air policy to educate people on the dangers of second-hand smoke.

∫ Dec. 22, 1987: Warren City Council passed an ordinance championed by councilman George Lockwood, D-at large, to restrict smoking in most public buildings in the city. The ordinance, to go into effect July 1, 1988, will prohibit smoking in banks, professional offices, public transportation vehicles, theaters, courtrooms and most retail stores, and restrict smoking to designated areas in restaurants, hotels, malls and buildings owned, leased or operated by the city.

The Struggle

"It's hard to look back and know how far we've come," Hineman said. "We got lots of threats and hate mail when trying to do it. It was too novel. I got death threats."

She said her aversion to smoking didn't come from allergies or hypersensitivity to smoke. It was the numerous health dangers -- increased chances of lung disease, stroke, cancer, pregnancy complications, type 2 diabetes mellitus, rheumatoid arthritis and cataracts, among other problems -- and her own family.

Hineman said she grew up in a house with a continual layer of her father's cigar smoke hanging in the air. She ducked her head to run through it when she needed to go upstairs. She said her mom smoked Virginia Slims because "everybody else was doing it." Hineman said she remembers how the cigarettes made her mother cough and hack. She died at age 39.

Hineman said she determined to live a life filled with fresh air. But at the time, adults were permitted to smoke everywhere, even in hospitals and in school gymnasiums during student plays and sports.

In 1985, she began to work with Lockwood on creating smoke-free zones, if not in the entire state, at least in Cortland and Warren businesses. While Cortland never approved a city smoking ban, Warren did in 1987. Lockwood retired in 1998 as Warren deputy health commissioner, and passed away in 2013.

"George Lockwood started the fight in Warren. I worked in Cortland. We joined up," Hineman said.

"She started it," Abruzzi said. He turned toward Hineman. "You started all this, but there was no (anti-smoking) movement."

"People would talk but nobody would do anything," Jack Hineman said.

"If you don't like this, you need to speak up," Robyn Hineman said.

Lockwood and Robyn Hineman worked on what they considered compromise legislation. It wasn't a total ban on smoking, but it would limit the areas where smoking would be permitted. It wasn't ideal, she said, because smoke drifts.

"We don't mind that you want to smoke, but you can't keep it in your area," Jack Hineman said. "It gets onto us and our food."

Abruzzi said, "I was against the smoking ban, but what Robyn and George Lockwood came up with, I could live with it. There were no restrictions on percentage of restaurant that had to be nonsmoking. We made our lounge area the smoking area.

"(The city ordinance) allowed for if we needed a smoking area, we could," Abruzzi said. "I didn't like it. But you want everybody in the same boat. Warren had a law we could live with."

His business put in a nonsmoking area before the legislation passed, partly because he also served on the local board of the American Heart Association.

"People would come to me and say, 'Bob, how could you of all people not have a nonsmoking area?' So I put one in. It was kind of screwy. A third of the dining room was smoking and two-thirds of it was nonsmoking, but they might sit next to each other.

"We didn't go smoke-free until the Ohio law passed."

Smoke Free State

On Nov. 7, 2006, voters passed what was called the statewide Smoke-Free Workplace Act. The law took effect Dec. 7, 2006, and enforcement began May 3, 2007.

The law prohibits smoking in most places of employment, including restaurants, retail stores, hospitals and government buildings.

Ohio became the 12th state to pass such a law and the first Midwestern state and the first tobacco-growing state to enact such a ban, according to the Ohio Department of Health.

ODH estimates there are some 280,000 public places and places of employment in the state that are covered by the ban, and that anyone who visits or works in those places should not be exposed to secondhand smoke.

Violators are subject to fines increasing to $2,500 an incident for continued violations.

"That's the biggest thing I thought I'd never see in my life is when Ohio went smoke-free," Hineman said. "Now it's been 10 years and we don't even remember when people smoked everywhere."

"It's almost not an issue now," Abruzzi said.

He said Warren's Clean Indoor Air Ordinance passed in December 1987 was better for businesses than what Ohio voters approved. The statewide ban took away choice.

Jack Hineman said, "The cry was, 'You're taking away my rights. I have the right to smoke if I choose to.' Well, you're taking away my right to breathe -- and breathing is not an option."

Robyn Hineman said, "I am happy. I am happy now. My next wish would be that parents think of what they're doing to their children and pets who have no say-so in what they're doing."

bcole@tribtoday.com

Starting at /week.